My American Idol Opinion

Okay, I'm not trying to offend anybody by writing this. So if you don't agree I'm sorry... :(

Alrighty Lee has an awesome voice but think of all the late-night teenage girls out there that don't vote based on that. His voice is awesome and he's exciting onstage but he's SOOO boring and awkwardly depressing when he's just talking!

Big Mike (Michael Lynch) is very sweet and when I first saw him at the auditions I thought he would be just another one of those funny auditions but he sings awesome! He's got the whole thing where people love his story and personality as well as his voice!

Didi (I'm only writing her cuz she was on tv not too long ago) was cool and cute and she had this interesting beautiful voice that really fixed up a ton of really lame songs, If she couldn't sing like that, her song choices would've eliminated her in the first place! But she just picked tooo many bad songs and fell down on the cement and burned like a deceased worm. (No she's not a worm that's just what happened to her :P)

Tim Urban crashes and burns onstage. And this is what happens for me: I forget how terrible he is during the later week and when he's blabbing with people offstage because he's so "funny and cute" And then he sings and I hate him again!!!!

As for David Archuleta, (Aaron Kelly) He just sings the same every single week! I forget every single song he sung and often forget him completely! (You people are lucky I remembered him now!) I didn't like David and I didn't like Kris Allen, so I don't like him!

Siobhan Magnus is really strange and funny and darling in a way I like, but this is what happened to her, she was strange and I never remembered her, then she did the CRAZY sweet awesome song where she hit a MAD high note, and then she got so much applause from that that I think everyone started expecting too much from and she spiraled downward like and airplane that lost a wing, but repaired the wing with duct tape (Belting out a incredible highnote) but as you know duct tape only last so long and the judges were there to rip off the tape and leave scratch marks, and that's what happened on Tuesday.

Katie is just too young and the trouble is she doesn't grasp the fact that she sing like a thirty year old at a karaoke bar and doesn't try at all to change her voice younger! And I completely know what Simon is talking about saying she should go country, she needs to go to a Miley Cyrus concert and stay taped down in a seat until she can sing younger! (I hate Miley but she is country-ish and look WHERE it's gotten HER!!!)

I like Crystal alot and love her little story and vibe but I feel like maybe she doesn't belong on THIS show, she has been seemingly kind of on edge and kind of homesick almost, but she sings awesome and now that Didi's gone she only has one girl to worry about, Siobhan lol. I love her! And being the only young mom on there she gets an edge up, and so does Big Mike! :) <3


Andrew is just kind of boring and I'm liking him less every week, but he did good on the Usher week and I really like his little family and his whole story! :3

I don't even wanna write anymore but here's Casey James: I don't get why he smiles so much, I don't like his bluesish country songs and I don't think he's cute! I don't get it! Why is it he's never been in the bottom? How come he's still on the show? How come he's popular but all the American Idol subjects online never mention him? I dont know but I dislike him ALOT!


I think that's everone please comment!